EAC. it never fails me unless I have an old CD with horrid scratches. Accurip is a nice feature. In the case of a tiny anomaly from a scratch, it it uses Internet comparisons to fill in the missing gaps.

I tag after the fact with MP3Tag. I keep my genres very simple so I usually like to tweak what the 'Interweb' recommended, make sure my track numbers have leading zeros, etc. It's easy and very fast.

With great power comes Awesome irresponsibility.